I’ve read plenty of articles by now that cover how much people might be exposing themselves to identity theft through social networking and social sharing sites. But I’ve had a different worry over the past year or so. Is all my twittering, Flickr posting, Facebooking and so on putting my kids in danger?
Think about it. I’m not just exposing myself online as I share things with my now 2,000 followers on Twitter or my 1,500 “friends” on Facebook or anyone who sees a photo I leave public on Flickr. I’m giving away details of my life to strangers that could let a crazy person make themselves seem familiar to one of my kids.
Chills. I got chills after writing the sentence above. And I’ve thought about it for some time, pondering whether I should even do a post about it, for fear that just talking about the potential danger might make it more real. But I think it’s an important issue that few are really considering and one without an easy answer. Below, some of what I’ve been thinking about and doing to reduce the danger.
I don’t want to throw up the shutters and withdraw from social activity on the web. I enjoy twittering, and it’s fun to have photos up on Flickr so that I can make them show in places like on my blog. Tim Bray recently likened Twitter to being like a corner coffee shop, and I like walking into the shop, talking with some of my friends and even some people I don’t know well there, because I make new friends that way.
It’s also hard for me to withdraw socially when much of what I do revolves being on both virtual and physical stages. In particular as a marketer, social sites are places I want to be, making connections and networking virtually as I would do in life.
In fact, I just came back from our SMX Sydney show, where I did plenty of real-life networking that involved talking about my personal life with people and hearing about their personal lives. When did I arrive? When am I leaving? And your family is back where? You’re going to do what next week? Completely innocent questions that are asked and answered without a second thought — but do the same thing online, and they become a record of your current and future movements that might be used in ways you don’t expect.
To date, I don’t think I’ve ever named my kids on this blog. I’ll refer to them as my “oldest” or “youngest” but not use their actual names. That was a conscious decision. I didn’t want their names out there, for fear of aforementioned crazy people, scary strangers, whatever. Similarly, I didn’t put their pictures into my Flickr photostream until a few months ago, so that someone might know I have kids but not have any idea what they look like. They’d be on Flickr, but they pictures were restricted to friends and family.
One problem with my great master plan is that it didn’t take into account friends. I’ve had friends who know my children and both talk about them by name and post pictures online. If you were really looking, you’d figure it out. Aside from friends, occasionally my kids would be with me at a conference, so would meet someone there who might then mention the encounter online.
I don’t fault my friends or those I’ve met for any of this. It’s not like I wrapped the kids up in big “do not blog” bubble wrap clothing. No one did any of this with intent to cause harm, nor would I even say they were thoughtless in it. Rather, I think we’ve been fortunate that to date, online has remained a largely happy, safe place to share and talk about things.
Instead of hiding my kids, I think the solution is that I’ll have to educate them more. “Stranger Danger” means I know need to explain that Daddy shares some things online, and if anyone comes along that seems to know a lot about what you’ve done, where we’ve gone and so on, that doesn’t mean they are your friend or that you should trust them. I’m really pondering the best way to explain all this, so that I don’t freak them out yet keep them safe.
To give you some perspective, they’ve never even really had the basic stranger danger talk from me yet. That’s because they’ve grown up in a small English village, where no one plays in the street as I did as a Southern California kid. They’ve been driven to school not out of laziness but because it’s way too far to walk and generally have never been out of sight of either me or my wife. But our move back to suburban Southern California’s going to mix them with many more people, plus as they’re getting to that age where I might let them walk places on their own. Chills, again, even thinking about that. Maybe I’ll keep them under escort until 16
Clearly, they need the talk. And clearly to me, that needs to include how people could make it seem like they know us, when they don’t. Scary stuff, and part of me wonders how much I created the problem inadvertently or if rather, it’s inevitable for anyone who spends much time online these days.
I’ve also pondered pulling back on some of the personal stuff I share online. This is hard for reasons I’ve mentioned already plus as a writer, not being able to talk about my family prevents me from doing more of the personal writing that I want to explore more. What’s the balance?
As I said, I don’t plan to pull the shutters down. But I have been already and probably will be more careful about what I do share, along with doing the proper education of my kids.
Ironically, when I moderated our Teens & Search panel at SMX West, the teens on the panel expressed that kids needed more education that what they share on social sites could be used against them. Certainly there have been plenty of articles on this topic, too. But parents and adults need that education too. What you share isn’t just exposing you. It’s exposing others (and see Vanessa’s excellent post on this from last year).
I think about that a lot beyond my kids. I generally don’t post pictures of people who I don’t think have been in a public view. And if I write or twitter about someone, I ask myself carefully if they’re going to mind, if they’re already talking about such things themselves.
{ 9 comments }
I inadvertantly used my daughters name on Twitter the other day and had the same concerns. Hard to know what the right balance is. — Derrick [Last name withheld]
I agree the internet is filled with scoundrels, When my kids were young I gave them spy names, and when someone asked their name they used the spy name unless we told them that it was OK to use their real name. If I hear someone using their spy name around me and my kids I get ready for battle.
I sooooo feel your pain on this one. Drop me an email I can help you close one of the “contact points” that helped me figure out their names.
I’m not exactly a kid anymore, although I still get a little freaked when people I’ve never met before ask me questions about things in my personal life or past. I still haven’t got to grips with the merging lines of offline and online conversations, despite being weaned on the www. I’m dreading the day when I’m in your situation and would probably try to completely separate personal and work life online.
Very good points there, Danny.
I’ve been thinking about the same, do I need seperate accounts on Flickr and YouTube for personal and work related stuff?
I was thinking about doing a travel blog about me and families travels and that raises alot of concerns about security. It’s difficult to have such a blog with out pictures of the kids, travel dates and location. I don’t want to let some potential waco restrict what I can do, but how much information is safe to put out there?
I think there are lots people concerned with privacy and the free flow of information. I’m on Geni now and so are hundreds of family members including numerous kids.
You bring up some really good points.
Good article Danny.
Just happened across this, and it was like reading something I had written. Your kids might be about the same age as mine, based on the Club Penguin reference.
The comment about friends being a risk you don’t think about is so true. But I’m guessing your kids are not really IM-ing and emailing their friends at school, because that’s where it becomes really problematic. I drummed into my daughter never to communicate with strangers online. Really, I went overboard perhaps.
In my case, a kid in my daughter’s peer group introduced several other kids into her email CC fields and also on IM. Suddenly, you have all these strangers with your kids’ email address and IM. The other kids start communicating with your kid. And since they’re “friends” of a friend, your kids just accept them. And they will. The entire class my daughter is in did exactly as she did.
Worst is when you can’t verify anything about the other kids, or even that they are kids. In my case, they were using anonymous Gmail accounts, so I couldn’t check to see the originating IP addresses to verify that one of these “kids” was in England as was claimed. Which actually would have been nice to know because we don’t live in England and this one kid was writing weird, probing questions that gave me chills. Google really should fix that anonymous thing. No one else does it.
Anyway, just thought this might help you. Tell your kids never to communicate with anyone they have never actually met in real life and consider their friend. “Friends of a friend” are a big problem, and I never thought of this until it happened.
I was just thinking the same thing about my kid, again… I’m pretty much all the way out there, living online like that guy who publishes his SSN. At times it freaks me out. Which lead me to install security cameras with DVRs and an alarm at my house. After some serious souls searching a few years ago, I even went out and bought some actual protection, which is it’s own inherent internal security risk. Having a gun at the house is not the way I would have chosen to live.
At this point for me, it’s almost like there’s no turning back. And because of my own actions, I watch my kid closer than I think is necessary for her social development. Overprotective? Maybe. It’s kind of sad, really. But this is the information age, and security risks are far different than they used to be.
I’m not hard to find, and I am a proud parent. And just to throw it out there, I will shoot an intruder if you come to my house. Remember that if there are any freaks reading this *looks over shoulder*
That’s so old school, it’s actually embarrassing… but I made my bed and now my family has to lie in it.
I suppose the next step is to educate my child as much as possible eh? Don’t talk to strangers, never open the door, and don’t touch Daddy’s gun. Oh man what have I gotten myself into…
It’s a great idea to also use misleading or incorrect information about kids – or anyone – whose privacy is important. When registering for social networking sites, keep a spreadsheet of birthdays that you use – I tend to use a different birthday for different sites, so that if I start getting birthday reminders/ads etc. from a third party, I can look at the chart and know who was selling data.
Get good at detective work – I had the experience recently (december) of trying to track down a student who had gone missing in real life using social networks, and happily that worked out well.
Comments on this entry are closed.