The Nook Color Is Android 2.2? That’s An Embarrassment To Android Devices Everywhere

At the end of April, I read that the Nook Color was turning into an Android 2.2 device. Cool! I wanted a slip, cheap Android tablet. But in reality, calling the Nook an Android device is an embarrassment to Android devices everywhere.

Cast your mind back to when the Android 2.2 “Froyo” upgrade news went around. Among the headlines from Techmeme at the time, the lead item was a ZDnet piece that gave the impression the Nook was now an Android 2.2 tablet. From the story:

There’s no need to hack the Nook Color into an Android tablet anymore as B&N is giving out the power for free. The biggest feature found in the v1.2 firmware update is the inclusion of Android 2.2….

Speaking of familiar apps, there are plenty available in Nook Apps that we’ve seen elsewhere now optimized for this device, such as Pulse (as seen on the iPad), Epicurious, Lonely Planet phrasebooks, and of course, Angry Birds. (Let’s face it: no device that supports gaming apps could go without Angry Birds these days.

No need to hack the device, right? Because now it was Android 2.2 and it could run Android apps. Except, as I’ll get into, it doesn’t really run Android apps. It only runs Nook apps.

To be fair to ZDnet, it, like many of the other publications reporting on the news, did say that there was a special Nook app store that only had about 125 applications at launch. As for Barnes & Noble, it buries the news about the Nook Color being upgraded to Android 2.2 midway down in its release from the time.

If It’s Android, Android Is Buried Six Feet Under

The reality is that while the Nook might be Android 2.2 under the hood, there’s so much of the Nook’s own operating system layered above that the device has little to do with Android, in my opinion. It’s simply a Nook device, only able to run Nook apps — not Android apps — unless you want to hack it.

Consider if you decide to add more apps. You don’t get an Android market with thousands of apps but instead get routed to the walled garden of the Nook Apps area:

All The Apps You Can’t Use Elsewhere

Want Angry Birds, which the Nook press release talked about? There’s no free version, only a paid one:

I don’t mind buying apps, but if I’m going to buy an “Android” app, I’d like to use it on all my Android devices. But with the Nook, if you already own Angry Birds on another Android device, you won’t be able to use it. And if you buy the Nook version, that’s not going to work on your real Android devices.

Consider what happens if you go to Google’s Android Market on the web, to try and download and app for your Nook that way. Here’s me trying to put the Kindle on the Nook:

As you can see, I can’t send the app to the Nook because the Nook, despite supposedly being an Android 2.2 device, doesn’t register itself as such. In face, what’s the Nook Color really? The system settings screen makes it clear. Not Android 2.2 but rather a Nook 1.2 device.

Kindle On The Nook?

Now am I crazy to want to run Kindle on the Nook? When I returned my Nook, the salesperson seemed to find it weird. But me, I wanted a lightweight, inexpensive, touchscreen backlit device to read my Kindle books. Amazon’s own Kindle isn’t touchscreen or backlist. My iPad is often too heavy to hold comfortable. The Nook seemed a good fit. But in the end, I discovered it had little to do with Android.

Maybe Barnes & Noble will bring out a real Android-version of the Nook during its announcement next week. Maybe Amazon will turn release its own Android-powered Kindle device later this year, as reports suggest. In either case, if these devices will be called “Android” by the press, I think we need to set some minimum requirements for that.

At the very least, the device should be able to run any of the thousands of applications that would typically run on an Android device. Having its own app store with a tiny subset of apps that can’t be used on real Android devices is a sign it’s not really Android.


Comments

  1. Bob Bobjackson says

    So you didn’t do any research before buying a device worth hundreds of dollars and someone else is to blame?

    Hey I’ve got some beans to sell you, they are running Android 4.0, how much will you give me for them?

  2. says

    It’s worth $250. And I bought it in order to research it and perhaps keep it. When it didn’t prove to be what I wanted, I returned it within the return policy and got a full refund, no problem.

    So no, I’m not blaming anyone for somehow costing me money. That’s why I didn’t mention that issue at all in this post.

    Rather, I’m explaining that anyone who believes they are buying an Android device when they get the Nook is probably in for a number of unexpected surprises.

    The Android 4.0 beans aren’t due out until later this year, anyway :)

  3. says

    The surprises with Nook are many and unpleasant. We went through several defective Nooks before finally getting one that also became defective, just more slowly. The Nooks would start flipping pages randomly. This is amazingly annoying when you’re half way through a book. There appears to be a manufacturing quality control issue.

    I bought a Kindle, Nook and iPad to try them all out. Most definitely I’d never buy another Nook.

  4. dustin says

    hey… first of all i really like your blog. your writing is great and the layout and everything is clean

    i was just wondering if you could direct me to how you got those awesome sharing buttons. thanks!!

  5. dustin says

    woops. sorry wish i could delete my last post. but i searched your blog some more and found that you use ShareIt. Thanks for all the helpful info!

  6. Ryno says

    I’ve had the NookColor since January of this year. I’ve rooted and tested out a bunch of different roms. I’m in love with CM7. Once it’s hacked (a ten minute process), this is a pretty decent tablet. Will it unseat the iPad or Samsung GTab? Heck no, but you can’t get anything better for the price.

    I still primarily use it for reading, and I do have Kindle and Nook apps installed. It’s pretty awesome how the apps all sync now. Wherever I leave off on my Kindle app, it starts me there when I pick up my actual Kindle 3.

  7. says

    The only problem I really see with andriod tablets are that there are so many of them to pick from and so many devices. The mobile market for andriod has worked quite well but untill tablets catch on more still think people will want the ipad instead.

  8. says

    Barnes & Noble almost certainly subsidizes the Nook and as a result doesn’t want to allow the Kindle bookstore on the device. I almost don’t blame them, except that the B&N store is significantly more expensive than Kindle, and so you are much better off buying a Kindle device if you want books.

    D

  9. Nook Rooter says

    Ryno: “I’ve had the NookColor since January of this year. I’ve rooted and tested out a bunch of different roms. I’m in love with CM7. Once it’s hacked (a ten minute process), this is a pretty decent tablet. Will it unseat the iPad or Samsung GTab? Heck no, but you can’t get anything better for the price.”

    I also own a Nook Color that has been rooted. I’ve had mine since July, and I brought it across the boarder to Canada. I’m running a modded version of CM7 called Phiremod, and have overclocked my Nook to 1.2 GHz. It’s no iPad Killer, but it’s a great device once it’s rooted. I’m also running the Kindle app on it, and the free versions of Angry Birds. It does take a bit of work to get it to work as an Android Tablet, but once it’s done, it’s worth it. I would implore you to try it again, as it is quite simple to root, and to fix the Android Market compatibility. There are also so many ways you can root it. That’s what makes Android fun.

    The articles you linked are misleading to anyone who is interested in a Nook Color, and are geared more towards the less technically inclined, IMHO.